S.No
|
Questionnaire
|
Schedule
|
1.
|
Questionnaire is generally sent through mail to
informants to be answered as specified in a covering letter, but otherwise
without further assistance from the sender.
|
A
schedule is generally filled by the research worker or enumerator, who can
interpret the questions when necessary.
|
2.
|
Data
collection is cheap and economical as the money is spent in preparation of
questionnaire and in mailing the same to respondents.
|
Data collection is more expensive as money is
spent on enumerators and in imparting trainings to them. Money is also spent in preparing schedules.
|
3.
|
Non
response is usually high as many people do not respond and many return
the questionnaire without answering all questions. Bias due to non response
often remains indeterminate.
|
Non
response is very low because this is filled by enumerators who are able to
get answers to all questions. But even in this their remains the danger of
interviewer bias and cheating.
|
4.
|
It
is not clear that who replies.
|
Identity
of respondent is not known.
|
5.
|
The
questionnaire method is likely to be very slow since many respondents do
not return the questionnaire.
|
Information
is collected well in time as they are filled by enumerators.
|
6.
|
No
personal contact is possible in case of questionnaire as the questionnaires
are sent to respondents by post who also in turn returns the same by post.
|
Direct
personal contact is established
|
7.
|
This
method can be used only when respondents are literate and cooperative.
|
The
information can be gathered even when the respondents happen to be
illiterate.
|
8.
|
Wider
and more representative distribution of sample is possible.
|
There
remains the difficulty in sending enumerators over a relatively wider area.
|
9.
|
Risk
of collecting incomplete and wrong information is relatively more under the questionnaire
method, when people are unable to understand questions properly.
|
The
information collected is generally complete and accurate as enumerators can
remove difficulties if any faced by respondents in correctly understanding
the questions. As a result the information collected through schedule is
relatively more accurate than that obtained through questionnaires.
|
10.
|
The
success of questionnaire methods lies more on the quality of the
questionnaire itself.
|
It
depends upon the honesty and competence of enumerators
|
11.
|
The physical appearance of questionnaire must be
quite attractive.
|
This may not be the case as schedules are to be
filled in by enumerators and not by respondents.
|
12.
|
This is not possible when collecting data through questionnaire.
|
Along with schedule observation method can also be
used.
|
Saturday, October 6, 2012
Difference between Schedule and Questionnaire.
Definition of Data and its source
What is Data, explain type of
sources to collect data and information?
Ans: Data is a collection of facts, such as
values or measurements. It can be numbers, words, measurements, observations or
even just descriptions of things. Data
can be qualitative (descriptive information) or quantitative (numerical
information).
Data is typically the
results of measurements and can be visualized using graphs or images. Raw data, i.e., unprocessed data, refers to a
collection of numbers, characters; data processing commonly occurs by
stages, and the "processed data" from one stage may be considered the
"raw data" of the next. Field data refers to raw data collected in an
uncontrolled in situ environment. Experimental data refers to data generated within
the context of a scientific investigation by observation and recording.
Type of sources to collect data and
information:
For many
years, scientific methods have dominated the field of evaluation. These methods
seek to establish cause-effect relationships, produce generalizable results and
provide quantitative data through structured data collection procedures.
Alternative methods have gained recognition over the past years in the effort
to understand complex social conditions. Given the varied approaches to
evaluation, there is no single list or categorization of data collection
methods. Methods such as observation and open-ended interviews seek to explore
situations in depth. As a result, we now have an array of techniques to choose from. A listof methods which can be followed are
listed below. Some of which are useful for collecting data in social science
research methodologies (survey, case study). Some are geared toward collecting
quantitative (numeric) data; others toward qualitative (narrative) data. Some
may be more appropriate for certain samples or resource considerations. There
are two types of data:
Primary Data:
collected for the first time.
Secondary Data:
those which have already been collected and analyzed by someone else.
METHODS TO COLLECT PRIMARY DATA:
1.
Observation method:
Commonly used in behavioural sciences.
It is the gathering of data by investigator’s own direct observation of
relevant people, actions and
situations. Observation is a primary method of collecting data by human,
mechanical, electrical or electronics means with direct or indirect contact. As
per Langley P, “Observations involve looking and listening very carefully in
order to discover particular information.”Observation is the main source of
information in the field research. The researcher goes into the field and
observes the conditions in their natural state.
The observation is important and actual
behavior of people is observed and not what people say they did or feel. For
example, people value health but they would pick up food they know to fatty. It
is useful when the subject cannot provide information or can only provide
inaccurate information like people addicted to drugs. But at the same time, in
observation the researcher does not get any insight into what people may be
thinking. There are many types of observation such as:
1. Direct
or indirect
2. Structured
(for descriptive research) or
Unstructured (for exploratory research)
3.
Participant or Non- participant observation
4.
Disguised observation
5.
Obtrusive or non-obtrusive
2.
Survey method:
This
method refers to collecting
standardized information through structured questionnaires to generate
quantitative data. Surveys may be mailed
(surface and electronic), completed on-site or administered through interviews,
conducted either face-to-face, by
telephone or electronically. Sample
surveys use probability sampling which allows to generalize findings to a
larger population, while informal surveys do not. Surveys are based on short interviews either face-to-face
or on telephone. These are based on simple questions. Also, there are
computer-assisted interviews. Survey can be performed by sending a
questionnaire and quantifying the response when questionnaires are returned. This
approach is most suited for gathering descriptive information. In a survey,
usually general questions are asked to know what customers or subjects do and
think. But if one wants to know ‘why they feel that way’, one has to conduct an
in-depth research. In survey, answers may depend on the mood of the respondent.
As such, the survey shows how one feels at one particular time
There are many types of surveys such as:
1.
Structured Surveys: In this method formal lists of questions are asked of
all respondents in the same way.
2.
Unstructured Surveys: In this method interviewer probe respondents and guide
the interview according to their answers.
3.
Direct Approach: The researcher asks direct questions about behaviors
and thoughts.
4.
Indirect Approach: The researcher ask question and from the response, the
researcher may be able to discover the answer of his/ her question.
3. Contact
methods:
Information
may be collected by:
1. Mail
2. Telephone
3.
Personal
interview:
In this method information is collected by talking with and listening to
people. Interviews range on a continuum from those which are tightly structured
(as in a survey) to those that are free-flowing and conversational.
4.
In-depth techniques: In
in-depth research, long and probing interviews are taken to find out customers
satisfaction and loyalty, usage, awareness and brand recognition etc. and this
can be done as by ways mentioned below:
·
Focus group
·
Panels
·
In-depth interviews
·
Projective methods
5.
Case study: is an in-depth examination of a particular case
program, group of participants, single individual, site, or location. Case
studies rely on multiple sources of information and methods to provide as
complete a picture as possible.
6.
Group assessment: collecting and evaluating information through the
use of group processes such as a nominal group technique, focus group, Delphi,
brainstorming, and community forums.
7.
Expert or peer review: examination by a review committee, a panel of
experts or peers.
8.
Questionnaires :A questionnaire consists
of a set of questions presented to a respondent for answers. The respondents
read the questions, interpret what is expected and then write down the answers
themselves. It consists of a number of questions printed or typed in a definite
order. These forms are actually mailed to the respondent who was expected to
read and understand the questions and reply to them by writing the relevant
answers in the spaces provided. Its purpose is to collect information from the
respondents who are scattered over a vast area. Questionnaire include
open-ended questions and close-ended questions. Open-ended questions allow the
respondent considerable freedom in answering. However, questions are answered
in details. Close-ended questions has to be answered by the respondent by
choosing an answer from the set of answers given under a question just by
ticking.
Following are the
different types of Questionnaire used by social scientists and anthropologists.
·
Structured questionnaire: It include definite, concrete and
pre-obtained questions which were prepared in advance.
·
Closed-form questionnaire: It is used when categorized data is required.
·
Pictorial questionnaire: It is used to promote interest in answering
after seeing the pictures on a particular theme.
·
Unstructured questionnaire: Designed to obtained
view points, opinions, attitudes and to show relationships and
inter-connections between data.
9.
Schedule:A schedule is a structure of set of questions on a
given topic which are asked by the interviewer or investigator personally. The
order of questions, the language of the questions and the arrangement of parts
of the schedule are not changed. However, the investigator can explain the
questions if the respondent faces any difficulty. It contains direct questions
as well as questions in tabular form.Schedule include open-ended questions and
close-ended questions. Open-ended questions allow the respondent considerable
freedom in answering. However, questions are answered in details. Close-ended
questions has to be answered by the respondent by choosing an answer from the
set of answers given under a question just by ticking
4.
Experimental Method:
1.
Also called Empirical Research or Cause and Effect Method, it is a
data-based research, coming up with conclusions which are capable of being
verified with observation or experiment. Experimental research is appropriate
when proof is sought that certain variables affect other variables in some way.
Such research is characterized by the experimenter’s
control over the variables under study and the deliberate manipulation of one
of them to study its effects. In such a research, it is necessary to get at
facts first hand, at their source, and actively go about doing certain things
to stimulate the production of desired information.
· Researcher must provide self with a working hypothesis or guess as to the
probable results.
· Then should work to get enough facts (data) to prove
or disprove the hypothesis.
· Then sets up experimental designs which he thinks
will manipulate the persons or the materials concerned so as to bring forth the
desired information.
Evidence gathered through experimental or empirical
studies today is considered to be the most powerful support possible for a
given hypothesis.
2.
Simulation: use of models or mock ups to solicit perceptions
and reactions.
5. Other Methods:
·
Portfolio review: a collection of materials, including samples of work
that encompassthe breadth and scope of the programor activity being evaluated.
· Testimonial:a statement made by aperson indicating personal
responses andreactions.
· Test:
use of
established standards to assessknowledge, skill, or performance such as
apen-and-pencil or skills test.
· Photograph, slide, and video:uses photographyto
capture visual images.
· Diary
and journal:
recording of eventsover time revealing the personal perspectiveof the
writer/recorder.
· Log:recording of chronological entrieswhich are usually
brief and factual.
· Document
analysis:use of
content analysisand other techniques to analyze andsummarize printed material
and existinginformation.
· Action
cards: use of index
cards on which participants record what they did the action and when they
reached their goal; primarily used in self-assessment.
· Problem
story: narrative
account of past, present, or future situations as a means of identifying
perceptions. Using fictional characters
externalizes the problem situation.
· Creative
expression: use of
art forms to represent peoples ideas and feelings through stories, drama,
dance, music, art.
· Unobtrusive
measures:
gathering information without the knowledge of the people in the setting; for
example, examination of record books to identify areas of greatest activity;
unobtrusive observations of playground interactions to record aggressive behaviours.
· On some occasions, variety of non traditional
techniques are also used for getting people to talk or express themselves for
evaluation purposes.
METHODS
TO COLLECT SECONDARY DATA:
Sources can be
classified as:
1.
Paper-based sources – books, journals, periodicals, abstracts, indexes,
directories, research reports, conference papers, market reports, annual
reports, internal records of organizations, newspapers and magazines.
2.
Electronic sources– CD-ROMs, on-line databases, Internet, videos and
broadcasts.
The main sources of qualitative and quantitative
secondary data include the following:
1.
Official or government sources.
2.
Unofficial or general business sources.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)